What an 18-month-old and a three-year-old are meant to be doing, and why the lists disagree

Bottom line

  • A milestone on the current CDC list is something 75% or more of children do by that age. On older lists it meant about half. Check which kind you are reading.
  • The lists agree on the big flags: not walking at 18 months, no words at 18 months, no two-word phrases at 2.
  • They disagree on 50 words: 24 months on older lists, 30 on the CDC's. If your two-year-old has few words, mention it.
  • Look at the lists at check ages. One miss means a conversation with your GP or child health nurse. A lost skill means go now.
Evidence: Moderate Evidence: Weak

Last reviewed

This page is a parent's summary of published guidance and research. It is not a screening tool and not medical advice. If you are worried about your child, talk to your GP or child health nurse. In Queensland you can call 13 HEALTH (13 43 25 84) and ask for a child health nurse. Disclaimer.

I have two boys, one 18 months old and one three. Both are due a child health check in Queensland about now, so I sat down with the milestone lists.

The first thing I found is that the lists don't agree with each other. The reason is worth knowing before you read any of them.

A listed age can mean two different things

The list most apps and websites borrow from is the American one, published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). It was rewritten in 2022.

Before the rewrite, a milestone listed at an age meant roughly the average. Half of all healthy children had not reached it yet. After the rewrite, a listed milestone is one that 75% or more of children show by that age. It was set late on purpose, so that a miss means something and nobody is told to wait and see.

The change was large. The authors cut about a quarter of the old milestones, replaced about 40%, and moved a third of the ones they kept to a different age, mostly an older one (Zubler et al. 2022; grade: strong that this is what the revision did).1

So "by 18 months" on an old list and "by 18 months" on the current one are different claims. A child who looks behind on an old list may be squarely typical.

Two other sources work differently again. Raising Children Network, the Australian parenting site, describes what children "might" or "probably" do across an age band, and keeps a separate short list of things to be concerned about.3 The World Health Organization gives windows for six movement skills. Its window for walking alone runs from 8.2 to 17.6 months.4 That is more than nine months wide, in healthy children.

Where the lists pull apart

Skill CDC (75% of children) Another source says What I take from it
Walking alone By 18 months WHO window ends at 17.6 months. Raising Children Network: not walking at 18 months is a concern They agree. Not walking at 18 months is worth raising.
First words Tries three or more words besides "mama" and "dada" by 18 months Raising Children Network: no single words at 18 months is a concern They agree. No words at all at 18 months is worth raising.
Two words together By 2 years Raising Children Network lists it as a concern at 18 months and again at 2 Mention it at 18 months. It becomes a real flag at 2.
About 50 words By 30 months Older average-age lists said about 24 months (not verified to an original source) The best-known dispute. See below.
Four milestones as the lists give themAge ruler from 6 to 36 months. Walking alone: range from 8.2 to 17.6 months (WHO window). Walks without holding on: most children by 18 months; no start age is published (CDC, 75% of children). Two words together: most children by 24 months; no start age is published (CDC, 75% of children). About 50 words: most children by 30 months; no start age is published (CDC, 75% of children).Age in months61218243036Walking aloneWHO window, 8.2 to 17.6 moWalks without holding onMost children by 18 mo (CDC, 75%)Two words togetherMost children by 24 mo (CDC, 75%)About 50 wordsMost children by 30 mo (CDC, 75%)Four milestones as the lists give themAge ruler from 6 to 36 months. Walking alone: range from 8.2 to 17.6 months (WHO window). Walks without holding on: most children by 18 months; no start age is published (CDC, 75% of children). Two words together: most children by 24 months; no start age is published (CDC, 75% of children). About 50 words: most children by 30 months; no start age is published (CDC, 75% of children).Age in months61830Walking aloneWHO window, 8.2 to 17.6 moWalks without holding onMost children by 18 mo (CDC, 75%)Two words togetherMost children by 24 mo (CDC, 75%)About 50 wordsMost children by 30 mo (CDC, 75%)

Pencil shading between two marks: a published range. Both ends are from the source.

One pencil notch: the age by which most children do it. No start age is published, so none is drawn.

Children reach each of these at different ages, and later is often still typical. This chart is not a screening tool.

Sources: WHO Motor Development Study 2006 (row one); CDC milestone lists as revised in 2022 (rows two to four).

On the 50 words: the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association was not involved in the 2022 rewrite and objected to several language items being moved later. It says the CDC lists are for keeping watch, not for clinical decisions, and it published its own milestones in 2023.5 A two-year-old with fewer than 50 words isn't flagged by the CDC list, but plenty of speech pathologists would want to have a look (grade: contested).

The 18-month-old

What most children do by 18 months, from the CDC list:2

  • Walks without holding on, and climbs on and off the couch
  • Scribbles
  • Tries to say three or more words besides "mama" or "dada"
  • Follows a one-step instruction without you pointing ("Give it to me")
  • Copies you doing jobs, such as sweeping
  • Points to show you something interesting
  • Drinks from an open cup with some spills, and tries a spoon

Also typical between 18 and 24 months, from Raising Children Network: starting to run, picking up one or two new words a week, the first simple pretending, tantrums, and playing near other children but not with them. Separation anxiety peaks at about this age.3

The one I'd underrated is pointing. Pointing to show you something, as opposed to pointing to get something, is one of the items clinicians watch most closely at this age.

The three-year-old

What most children do by 3, from the CDC list:2

  • Has a conversation with at least two back-and-forth exchanges
  • Asks "who", "what", "where" or "why"
  • Says what is happening in a picture
  • Is understood by other people most of the time
  • Strings large beads, and draws a circle when shown how
  • Puts on some clothes by himself and uses a fork
  • Calms down within about ten minutes of you leaving, say at childcare
  • Notices other children and joins in

Also typical between 3 and 4, from Raising Children Network: riding a tricycle, sentences of three to five words, pretend games with roles, and knowing the difference between happy, sad, afraid and angry. He is probably toilet trained by day. Wet nights are still common.3

Notice what is missing from the three-year-old's list: sharing, and doing as he's told. Most children can't reliably resist a forbidden thing until about three and a half to four (Zero to Three parent survey, read from a summary; grade: moderate).8 Neither is a milestone at this age.

How solid is all this

For movement and speech, reasonably solid. There is good data on when children do these things (grade: moderate).

For social and thinking skills, less so. The CDC authors say those items had the least data behind them. About 80% of the final milestones had measured data from at least one source, which means about one in five did not (grade: weak).1

At every age, two things outrank any list: trouble seeing or hearing, and losing a skill he once had. Raise the second one promptly.

What I do with it

I look at the lists at the check ages and leave them alone in between. In Queensland the checks relevant to us are at 18 months and between two and a half and three and a half. A child health nurse or GP does them. You book by calling 13 HEALTH (13 43 25 84) and asking for a child health nurse.7

Before each check I fill in the parent questions in the Red Book.6 Queensland's main screening questionnaire asks whether the parent has any concerns, area by area. In other words, "I'm a bit worried about his speech" is what the system is built to hear.

One "not yet" at a check age is a reason for a conversation, not for alarm. Between checks I act on a worry promptly and otherwise leave the lists shut. How we keep notes between checks is in following your child's development in two minutes a day.

None of this is a diagnosis. It is a way to notice things and turn up to the nurse with better notes.

Sources

  1. Zubler et al. 2022, Pediatrics. Evidence-informed milestones for developmental surveillance tools.
  2. CDC milestones at 18 months and 3 years.
  3. Raising Children Network, development at 18-24 months and 3-4 years.
  4. WHO Motor Development Study 2006.
  5. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, comments on the CDC milestone updates.
  6. Queensland Personal Health Record (Red Book).
  7. Queensland Government, child health checks.
  8. Zero to Three National Parent Survey (summary).

“Read” means the figure was read from the source itself. “Abstract” and “secondary” mean it was confirmed only from an abstract, press release or summary. “Not verified” means it could not be confirmed from the original. How we grade evidence.

What would change this advice

A new revision of the CDC or Raising Children Network lists, or Australian data on how many late talkers catch up.